Mapping Wuhan: Morphological atlas of the Urbanization of a Chinese City
Synopsis
Chinese cities have been expanding since the early 1980s under trends of rapid modernization, urbanization and globalization. Since then they have changed dramatically, and have in the process lost many of their traditional environments and spatial characteristics.
Urban planners and designers have been and are facing unprecedented challenges in China. They not only have to learn to understand the constantly emerging new urban mechanisms, and seek balance among stakeholders, but they also need to cope with the political pressures and the changing context under often extreme time pressure. In such circumstances, future- and design-oriented analysis based on a designerly way of thinking is useful—if not indispensable—for understanding the existing city and deciding on its transformations in a responsible and accountable way that is communicable among designers and with the public. This is especially so, in light of the growing awareness—also in China—of the value and importance of local urban identity, that is always—at least partially—based on history. In this atlas the Delft method of historical morphological analysis is applied to the city of Wuhan, valuing the importance of and finding meaning in the local urban identity of a city with a population over 11 million with a floating population of 14 million. The series of maps show the urban development, covering a century and a half.
Downloads
References
Beijer JHE (2013) Los Angeles. The Metropolis and Five Stages of Modernity.
The Netherlands, Delft: Delft University of Technology, Faculty of Architecture
and the Built Environment (Master thesis)
Bekkering HC (2006) ‘Stedenbouwkundig ontwerpen en cultuurhistorie/Urban
design and cultural history’. In Meyer H, Burg L van den (eds.) (2006) Het geheugen
van de stad. Cultuurhistorie en stedenbouwkundig ontwerp/The Memory of the
City. Cultural history and Urban Design. The Netherlands, Nijmegen: sun,
pp 26–39
——— (2008) ‘On Permanence in Urban Design.’ In Bekkering HC, Doeschgate A ten,
Hauptmann D, Heijer A den, Knaack U and Manen S van (eds.) The Architecture
Annual 2006–2007. The Netherlands, Delft: Delft University of Technology/
Rotterdam: 010 Publishers, pp 58–63
——— (2013) ‘On Permanence in Urban Design.’ In Rosemann J (ed.) PermaCity.
The Netherlands, Rotterdam: International Forum on Urbanism/Delft: Delft
University of Technology, pp 42–51
——— (2013). On Permanence in Urban Design. Lecture at the 10th China Urban
Housing Conference, Shanghai.
Bekkering HC, Cai J, Kuijper JA, Zhang K et al. (2017) Mapping Wuhan. A
Morphological Analysis of the Spatial Structure and the Urban Transformation
of Wuhan. The Netherlands, Delft: Delft University of Technology/People’s
Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan Land Use and Urban Spatial Planning
Research Center
Bekkering HC and Liu Y (2015) ‘Mapping Detroit: “The City of Holes.”’ In Thomas
JM and Bekkering HC (eds.) Mapping Detroit. Land, Community, and Shaping the
City. United States of America, Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press,
pp 27–50
Bracken G (2020) ‘The Shanghai Lilong. A new concept of home in China.’ In The
Newsletter. The Netherlands, Leiden: International Institute for Asian Studies,
pp 10–11
Bullock A, Stallybrass O and Trombley S (1988) The Fontana Dictionary of Modern
Thought. United Kingdom, London: Fontana Press (2nd ed.)
Burg L van den (ed.) et al. (2003) Urban Analysis Guidebook. The Netherlands, Delft:
Delft University of Technology, Faculty of Architecture
Cai J (2018) Design with forms as well as patterns. The Netherlands, Delft: Delft
University of Technology (PhD thesis)
Chen F and Thwaites K (2013) Chinese Urban Design, the Typomorphological
Approach. United Kingdom: Henry Ling Limited
Chen X (2009) The Role of Local Government, Property Developer and Public in
the Urban Regeneration – Case Study of Hanzhengjie, Wuhan, China. People’s
Republic of China, Wuhan: Huazhong University of Science and Technology
China Academy of Urban Planning & Design (2013) Wuhan 2049 Strategic Vision.
People’s Republic of China, Beijing: China Academy of Urban Planning & Design
China’s State Council (2010) Hubei Yangtze River Economic Zone Development Plan.
People’s Republic of China, Beijing: China’s State Council
——— (2014) Yangtze River Economic Zone Integrated Transport Corridor Planning
(2014–2020). People’s Republic of China, Beijing: China’s State Council
——— (2015) Development Plan of the Urban Agglomeration in the Middle Reaches of
the Yangtze River. People’s Republic of China, Beijing: China’s State Council
Chu D (2012) Enigmatic Code of the Netherlands: Cities, Architecture and Design
through an Architects Vision. People’s Republic of China, Beijing: China
Architecture & Building Press
Conzen MRG (1958) ‘The Growth and Character of Whitby’. In Daysh GHJ (ed.)
A Survey of Whitby and the Surrounding area. United Kingdom, Stratford-on-
Avon: The Shakespeare Head Press
——— (1960) Almwick, Northumberland. A Study in Town Plan Analysis. United
Kingdom, London: George Philip & Son
Compilation Committee (1998) The Historical Atlas of Wuhan. People’s Republic of
China, Beijing: SinoMaps Press
Cullen G (1961) The Concise Township. United States of America, New York, NY: Van
Nostrand Reinhold Company
Curry TM (2017) Form Follows Feeling. The Acquisition of Design Expertise and
the function of Aesthetics in the Design Process. The Netherlands, Delft: Delft
University of Technology (PhD thesis)
Dong F (2010) Wuhan modern city planning history research. People’s Republic of
China, Wuhan: Wuhan University of Technology
Dong J (2009) China City Construction History. People’s Republic of China, Beijing:
China Architecture & Building Press
Dong X (1929) Wuhan Special City Planning Guideline. People’s Republic of China,
Beijing: National Government
Duan J and Qiu G (2008) ‘The Emergence and Development of Overseas Urban
Morphology Study’. In Urban Planning Forum (5), pp 34–42
Dunnigan BL (2001) Frontier Metropolis: Picturing early Detroit, 1701–1838. United
States of America, Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press
Editorial Committee of Atlas of Wuhan (2015) Atlas of Wuhan. People’s Republic of
China, Beijing: Cartographic Publishing
Fan K (1823)/Jiang P et al. (1999) Hankou essays. People’s Republic of China,
Wuhan: Hubei People’s Press
Fang F (2020) Wuhan Diary. Dispatches from a Quarantined City (Berry M transl.).
United States of America, New York, NY: HarperCollinsPublishers
Fortier B (1989) La Métropole Imaginaire; Un Atlas de Paris [The Imaginairy
Metropolis; An Atlas of Paris]. Belgium, Brussels: Mardaga
Geurtsen R(1981) De Stad – Object van Bewerking [The City—Object of Operation].
The Netherlands, Delft: Delft University of Technology/TU Delft
——— (1988) Locatie Zuidpoort Delft. Stadsmorfologische atlas [Location Southgate
Delft. Atlas of urban morphology]. The Netherlands, Delft: Delftse Universitaire
Pers
Geurtsen R, Leupen B and Tjallingii S (1990) Werkboek Landschapskunde,
Architectuure, Stedebouw [Workbook Landscape Science, Architecture,
Urbanism]. The Netherlands, Delft: Delft University of Technology/TU Delft
Geurtsen R, Verhees J and Burgerova L (2009) History of European Urbanism from
Netherlands Perspective. Czech Republic, Prague: Česke vysoke učeni technike –
Faculta architectury [Czech National University – Faculty of Architecture]
Gu C (2015) ‘Editorial.’ In Urban Design and Planning, Volume 167 Issue DP6.
United Kingdom, London: Institution of Civil Engineers, p 237
Haas T and Westlund H (eds.) In the Post-Urban World. Emergent Transformation
of Cities and Regions in the Innovative Global Economy. United Kingdom: Taylor
& Francis, pp 96–106 [Series Regions and Cities]
Hankou City Construction Works Bureau (1936) Hankow Metropolitan Planning.
People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Hankou City Construction Works Bureau
Harvey D (1993) ‘From Space to Place and Back Again: Reflections on the condition
of postmodernity’. In Bird J, Curtis B, Putman T and Tickner C (eds.)
Mapping the Futures. Local Cultures, Global Change. (Chapter 1) United
Kingdom: Routledge
——— (1996) ‘The Environment of Justice.’ In Justice, Nature and the Geography of
Difference. United States of America, Malden, MA: Blackwell, pp 366–402
——— (2006) Spaces of Global Capitalism: A Theory of Uneven Geographical
Development. Unites States of America, New York, NY: Verso
Heeling Krop Bekkering Stedebouwkundigen en Architecten (1998) ‘De
vernieuwing van het centrum van Alphen aan den Rijn/The Renewal of
Alphen aan den Rijn Town Centre.’ In Harsema H (ed.) Landschapsarchitectuur
en stedebouw in Nederland/Landscape architecture and town planning
in the Netherlands. The Netherlands, Wageningen: Stichting Jaarboek
landschapsarchitectuur en stedebouw/Bussum: Uitgeverij thoth, pp 116–119
Heeling J, Meyer H, Westrik W et al. (2002) Het ontwerp van de stadsplattegrond
[The design of the plan of the city]. The Netherlands, Nijmegen: sun
Heizō I and Wallacker BE (1979) Chinese walled cities: a collection of maps from
Shina Jōkaku no Gaiyō. Hong Kong: The Chinese University Press
Hoeven C van der and Louwe J (1985) Amsterdam als stedelijk bouwwerk. Een morfologische
analyse [Amsterdam as urban building. A morphological analysis].
The Netherlands, Nijmegen: sun
Hoog M de (2005) ‘Bouwen tegen de klippen op. Eb en vloed in de woningbouw
sinds 1900’ [Building against obstacles. Low and high tide in house construction
since 1900]. In Ons Amsterdam [Our Amsterdam] 57. The Netherlands,
Amsterdam: Municipality of Amsterdam
Hooimeijer F and Maring L (2018) ‘The significance of the subsurface in urban
renewal.’ In Journal of Urbanism: International Research on Placemaking and
Urban Sustainability, pp 1–26
Hubei Provincial Government (1943) Wuhan Metropolitan Planning Draft. People’s
Republic of China, Wuhan: Hubei Provincial Government
——— (1945) Wuhan Regional Planning Committee Organization Regulations. People’s
Republic of China, Wuhan: Hubei Provincial Government
Kickert CC (2014) Active Centers – Interactive Edges. United States of America, Ann
Arbor: University of Michigan, Taubman College (PhD thesis)
——— (2019) Dream City – Creation, Destruction and Reinvention in Downtown
Detroit. United States of America, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
Koster EA (2001) Stadsmorfologie [Urban morphology]. The Netherlands,
Groningen: Rijksuniversiteit Groningen (PhD thesis)
Lefebvre H (1970) La Révolution Urbaine [The Urban Revolution]. France, Paris:
Gallimard
Leupen B, Graphe C, Kornig N, Lampe M and Zeeuw P de (1997 and later) Design
and Analysis. The Netherlands, Rotterdam: 010 Publishers (first edition in Dutch
Li Y, Yang P and Tang B (1989) Wuhan 1949–1989. People’s Republic of China,
Wuhan: Wuhan Press
Liu K (2017) Study on the evolution of urban form of three towns in Wuhan. People’s
Republic of China, Wuhan: Huazhong University of Science and Technology
Press
Liu P (2000) 理想家园:风水环境观的启迪 [The Concept of Ideal Home: Fengshui
Environment Enlightenment]. People’s Republic of China, Shanghai: 上海三联书
店 [Shanghai SDX Joint Publishing Company]
Long Y (2006) ‘Hanzhengjie: An Informal City.’ In Time Architecture 03/2006.
People’s Republic of China, Shanghai
Lootsma B (2000) Super Dutch: New Architecture in the Netherlands. United States
of America, Princeton: Princeton Architectural Press
Lynch K (1960) The Image of the City. United States of America, Cambridge, MA:
MIT Press
Marshall S and Calıskan O (2011) ‘A Joint Framework for Urban Morphology and
Design.’ In Built Environment 37(4), pp 409–426
McHarg IL (1969) Design with Nature. United States of America, New York, NY:
Natural History Press
Meyer H (1999) City and Port: urban planning as a cultural venture in London,
Barcelona, New York, and Rotterdam: changing relations between public urban
space and large-scale infrastructure. The Netherlands, Utrecht: International
Books
——— (2002) ‘Plan Analysis’. In Jong TM de and Voordt DJM van der: Ways to study
and research urban, architectural and technical Design. The Netherlands, Delft:
Delft University Press Science, pp 125–136
Meyer H and Burg L van den (eds.) (2006) Het geheugen van de stad. Cultuurhistorie
en stedenbouwkundig ontwerp/The Memory of the City. Cultural history and
Urban Design. The Netherlands, Nijmegen: SUN
Meyer H, Hoekstra MJ and Westrik J (2020) Urbanism. Fundamentals and Prospects.
The Netherlands, Amsterdam: Boom Uitgevers
Muratori S.(1959) Studi per una operante storia urbana di Venezia. [Study for an operative
urban history of Venice]. Italy, Rome: Instituto Poligraphico dello Stato
Muratori S, Bollati R, Bollati S and Marinucci G (1963) Studi per una operante storia
urbana di Roma. [Study for an operative urban history of Rome]. Italy, Rome:
Consiglio nazionale delle ricerche
Neutelings WJ (1988) De Ringcultuur: een studie naar het Ringmechanisme [Ring
Culture: a study of the Ring mechanism]. Belgium, Mechelen: Vlees en Beton
Oorschot LM (2014) Conflicten over Haagse stadsbeelden. Van Willemspark tot
Spuiforum [Conflicts over The Hague’s townscapes. From Willemspark to
Spuiforum]. The Netherlands, Delft: Delft University of Technology (PhD thesis)
Oostrum M van (2013) The cultivation of urban villages. Integration of informal development
in the formal planning process of Shenzhen. The Netherlands, Delft: Delft
University of Technology, Faculty of Architecture and the Built Environment
(Master thesis)
Palmboom F (1987) Rotterdam, verstedelijkt landschap [Rotterdam, urbanized landscape].
The Netherlands, Rotterdam: Uitgeverij 010
——— (2018) IJsselmeer: A spatial perspective. The Netherlands, Nijmegen: Vantilt
Publishers
Palmboom F and Fosso M (2014) Frits Palmboom: Inspiration and process in architecture.
Italy, Milan: Moleskine
Palmboom F and Thomaes S (2010) Drawing the Ground – Landscape Urbanism
Today: The Work of Palmbout Urban Landscapes. Switserland, Basel: Birkhauser
Panerai P (2008) Paris Métropole, Formes et échelles du Grand Paris [Paris
Metropolis, Forms and scales of Greater Paris]. France, Paris: La Villette
Panerai P, Castex J and Depaule J (1997) Formes Urbaines, de l’ilot à la Barre [Urban
Forms, from the Island to the Bar]. France, Marseille: Editions Parentheses
Panerai P, Castex J, Depaule J and Samuels I (2004) Urban Forms: The Death and
Life of the Urban Block. United Kingdom, Oxford: Architectural Press
Panerai P, Depaule J, Demorgon M and Veyrenche M (1980) Eléments d’Analyse
Urbaine [Elements of Urban Analysis]. Belgium, Brussels: Archives d’Architecture
Moderne
Panerai P and Lange L (2001) Formes Urbaines, Tissus Urbain: Essay de
Bibliographie Raisonné, 1940–2000 [Urban Forms, Urban Tissue: A Reasoned
Bibliographical Essay, 1940–2000]. France, Paris: Direction Generale de l’Urbanisme,
de l’Habitat et de la Construction
Pi M (2006) Wuhan General History. People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan
Press
Pinzon Cortes C (2009) Mapping Urban Form. Morphology studies in the contemporary
urban landscape. The Netherlands, Delft: Delft University of Technology
(PhD thesis)
Portoghesi P (ed.) (1980) The Presence of the Past. First International Exhibition of
Architecture. Italy, Milan: Electa Editrice
Rossi A (1982) The Architecture of the City. United States of America, New York, NY:
Institute for Architecture and Urban Studies (Opposition Books)
Rowe C and Koetter F (1978) Collage City. United States of America, Cambridge,
MA: MIT Press
Rowe WT (2008) Hankow. Conflict and Community in a Chinese City (1796–1895)
(Lou G transl.). People’s Republic of China, Beijing: China Renmin University
Press
Schoonderbeek MGH (2015) Place-Time Discontinuities: Mapping in Architectural
Discourse. The Netherlands, Delft: Delft University of Technology (PhD thesis)
Sennett R (2006) The Culture of the New Capitalism. United States of America, New
Haven, CT: Yale University Press
——— (2017) ‘The Open City.’ In Westlund H and Haas T (eds.) The Post Urban World.
United Kingdom, Milton Park: Routledge
Skidmore, Owings & Merrill/som (2013) Hanzheng Street Central Service District.
Skidmore, Owings & Merrill/som
Statistics Bureau of Wuhan City (2015) Wuhan Statistical Yearbook. People’s
Republic of China, Beijing: China Statistics Press
Tang L (2010) Population, Space and Hankou Urban Development (1460–1930).
People’s Republic of China, Beijing: China Social Sciences Press
Thomas JM and Bekkering HC (eds.) (2015) Mapping Detroit. Land, Community, and
Shaping a City. United States of America, Detroit, MI: Wayne State University
Press
Tschumi B (1995) The Manhattan Transcripts: Theoretical Projects. United States of
America, New York, NY: St. Martin’s Press/United Kingdom, London: Academy
Editions
Venturi R (1966) Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture. United States of
America, New York, NY: Museum of Modern Art
Venturi R, Scott Brown D and Izenour S (1972) Learning From Las Vegas. United
States of America, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
Vernez Moudon A (1994) ‘Getting to know the built landscape: Typomorphology.’ In
Franck KAS and Schneekloth LH Ordering space: types in architecture and design.
United States of America, New York, NY: Van Nostrand Reinhold, pp 289–311
——— (1997) ‘Urban Morphology as an emerging interdisciplinary field.’ In Urban
Morphology (1), pp 3–10
——— (2003) ‘A Catholic approach to organizing what urban designers should know.’
In Journal of Planning Literature vol. 6(4). United Kingdom, London: Institution
of Civil Engineers, pp 331–349
Wang P (1997) ‘Chapter viii: Tradition, Modernization and Human Existence.’ In
Philosophy and Modernization in China, Chinese Philosophical Studies xiii,
: pp 59–74. Cultural Heritage and Contemporary Change Series iii, Volume 13.
United States of America, Washington D.C.: The Council for Research in Values
and Philosophy
Whitehand JWR (1987) The Changing Face of Cities: A Study of Development Cycles
and Urban Form. United Kingdom, Oxford: Blackwell Publishers
——— (1990) ‘Townscape Management: Ideal and Reality’. In Slater TR and
Conzen MRG (eds.) The built form of western cities; essays for M.R.G. Conzen
on the Occasion of his Eightieth Birthday. United Kingdom, London: Leicester
University Press, pp 370–399
——— (2001) ‘British Urban Morphology: the Conzenian Tradition’. In Urban
Morphology, 5(2) p 103–109
Wu C, Wana Q and Dong X (2015) ‘Development Plan of the Urban Agglomeration
in the Middle Reaches of the Yangtze River.’ In Journal of Hubei University of
Economics 13(4), pp 5–10
Wu NI (1963) Chinese and Indian Architecture: The City of Man, the Mountain of God,
and the Realm of the Immortals. United States of America, New York, NY:
G. Braziller
Wu Z (2009) Planning Wuhan – 100 Years. People’s Republic of China, Beijing:
China Architecture & Building Press
Wuhan Architectural Design Institute (1944) Wuhan city flood control survey.
People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan Architectural Design Institute
Wuhan Geomatics Institute (2014) 2014 Annual Blue Book of Wuhan Geographic
Information. People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan Geomatics Institute
Wuhan Municipal Bureau of Statistics (2014) Wuhan Economic and Social
Development Statistics Bulletin. People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan
Municipal Bureau of Statistics
Wuhan Planning & Design Institute (1954) 1954 Wuhan Master Plan. People’s
Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan Planning & Design Institute
——— (1959) 1954 Wuhan Master Plan. People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan
Planning
——— (1982) 1982 Wuhan Master Plan. People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan
Planning
——— (1988) 1988 Wuhan Master Plan. People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan
Planning
——— (1996) 1996 Wuhan Master Plan. People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan
Planning
——— (2006) 2006 Wuhan Master Plan. People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan
Planning
——— (2010) 2010 Wuhan Master Plan. People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan
Planning
——— (2015) 武汉市第三批湖泊“三线一路”保护规划 [Three Lines and One Road,
Protection Plan of the Third Batch of Lakes in Wuhan City]. People’s Republic of
China, Wuhan: Wuhan Planning & Design Institute
Wuhan Regional Planning Committee (1945) Mega Wuhan Plan. People’s Republic
of China, Wuhan: Wuhan Regional Planning Committee
Wuhan University of Technology (2010) Wuhan modern city planning history research.
People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan University of Technology
Wuhan Urban Planning Administration (1999) Wuhan City Planning Annals.
People’s Republic of China, Beijing: China Architecture & Building Press
——— (2000) Wuhan City Planning Annals. People’s Republic of China, Beijing:
China Architecture & Building Press
——— (2010) Wuhan City Planning Annals. People’s Republic of China, Beijing:
China Architecture & Building Press
Xu G and Wang X (1684) Huguang Annals (Vol. 80). People’s Republic of China,
Wuhan: Hubei Kangxi Edition
Xu W, Liu Q et al. (ed.) (2010) Images and Interpretation of Wuhan City History.
People’s Republic of China, Wuhan: Wuhan Publishing House
Yu Z (2011) Spatial Establishment of Wuhan Urban Settlement. People’s Republic of
China, Beijing: China Architecture & Building Press
Zhang B and Zhou J (2015) ‘Urbanisation, urban planning and paradigms: new
theories, China’s practices and discussion.’ In Urban Design and Planning Volume
Issue DP6. United Kingdom, London: Institution of Civil Engineers,
pp 264–271
[without author]
长江经济带综合立体交通走廊规划 [Yangtze River Economic Zone Integrated
Transport Corridor Planning] (2014)
Wuhan Economic and Social Development Statistics Bulletin (2014)
Websites
www.bbs.cnhan.com
www.kongfz.com
www.meipian.cn/2cd9g2au
http://zhuanti.whjs.gov.cn/content/2009-09/17/content_178644.htm
Published
Categories
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
